The Table Podcast | Ep. 48-50: Self Trust: Why It’s The Relationship That Changes Everything with Matt Gottesman

These three episodes looked a little different than normal as I sat down with my friend Matt Gottesman in front of a live studio audience at Good Vibe Studios here in Phoenix, and we talked for long enough that squeezing it into one episode didn’t feel right. So it became a three-part series. This conversation deserved to be absorbed, not consumed. The topic was self-trust, and how the relationship you have with yourself shapes every other relationship you have, whether that’s your spouse, your team, or the people you’re meeting for the first time.

It starts with what gets taken away

Matt has been building online since 1999, and he’s a three-time founder who has worked with brands like Louis Vuitton and Moët Hennessy. But when I asked him to tell the room how he got where he is, he skipped the résumé and told the story of what was removed. A divorce after eight years of marriage. Contracts that disappeared within a day of him asking God for help. A business partnership that dissolved in 2019, the same year his father passed. He remembers watching his dad in a hospital bed, still taking care of everyone around him instead of resting, and how much that stayed with him. Then, just as he’d built an agency people could finally put a label on, he felt asked to move again, and he resisted it because the label was easy to explain.

I know a lot of people in that room have lived some version of this in the last year or two, doing one thing and then being told you’re not doing that anymore, and I include myself in that.

Putting yourself first isn’t selfish

That story led us to the thing I’m most guilty of, which is putting everyone else first. It can make you a great servant leader, and it can also become your Achilles heel, because if the vessel carrying you through everything else isn’t being cared for, it’s only a matter of time before it crashes. Matt’s version is that when you start your day with yourself, with gratitude and prayer and your health, there’s overflow. When you don’t, there’s only drain. He also said it was hard for him to let go of the giver identity, because when you want so much for people, putting yourself first feels wrong.

From there we got into noise, and how to know when to listen to outside voices and when you already had the answer. Matt said he can’t tell anyone what to do because he doesn’t know their path, and the best he can do is help them go deeper into their own answers. He also pointed out the contradiction we all live in, where the world says follow your intuition and then, the moment you do, asks you to show the evidence. You can’t produce the evidence until you’ve followed it. I admitted to the room that I’m bad at stillness and a compulsive fixer, and Matt’s take was that slow isn’t lazy, it’s precision. Decisions made from urgency are emotional decisions, and a lot of what we see in sales and marketing depends on you not slowing down enough to notice that.

You knew, so why did you keep going?

Part two is where it got personal. Matt told the room about a relationship that was heading toward marriage, how something felt off, and how he prayed over it and watched it end. When two friends later asked whether he’d known, he said yes, and that he kept going because he wanted it. I think about that a lot, because we have a built-in intelligence and it’s very easy to override it when something looks exactly like what we’ve been asking for.

I asked him how you tell peace from pressure, and his answer was one of the most useful things I heard all day. When you’re around the right people, you don’t over-edit and you don’t over-explain. You feel settled and fully yourself, and they actually call you further into yourself. If you’re around someone who has you contracting or bracing or explaining yourself, it doesn’t mean they aren’t peaceful people. It means they aren’t for you.

We also talked about what to do when you ignore all of that anyway. Matt’s advice was that if you’re going to do the opposite of what your gut says, do it self-aware. Stay curious, use it as practice, and ask what you’re missing. Over time you close the gap and recognize the pattern faster, until one day you’ve literally had enough and you yield. That reframed a lot of my own history with ignoring my gut.

The middle of the pivot

At one point I asked everyone in the room to raise a hand if they’d been through a massive pivot in the last twelve months, and most of the room did. When I asked who was in one right now, a lot of hands stayed up. We don’t talk about the middle nearly enough. We share the before and the after, but that in-between is where people most need someone to say “that does suck, and I’m here.” You don’t need a solution to start moving, and sometimes the first step is just saying it out loud to someone.

Matt added that his functional health doctors kept asking whether he had actually processed the last twenty years or just moved on quickly, the way entrepreneurs do. That’s a lot of us, and firstborn daughters in particular. I told the room about my first sound bath, where my brain went back and forth between emotional surrender and wondering what time we should order Pita Jungle. My body had no practice processing anything, and it showed.

When the room opened up

In part three the audience joined the conversation, and that’s the part I’d point people to first. One guest shared what it was like when his wife had open heart surgery three months after having twins, and how that season pushed him toward faith and community in a way he never had before. He’s now feeling called to speak to couples, and he was honest about the fear that comes with it, and about how he used to negotiate with fear. Matt told him that this work is also for him, because lived experience is what makes people trust you. They ask how you did it because they can see you’ve done the work.

Another woman shared that in one year she had bought a business, had a baby, and moved across the country, and that she kept trying to get back to the identity she’d had before. Matt’s response was that she’s being asked to let go of what was, because she isn’t meant to go back. I added that I had done something similar with my social media agency. It was doing great on paper, I knew it wasn’t mine anymore, and I couldn’t have shown up fully in the new thing while I was still running the old one. You can’t have one foot in and one foot out. Setting something down opens up space, and it’s hard to hear when something else is taking up all your time and energy.

Matt also shared an exercise he calls the average perfect day, a list of questions that walk you through what an ideal day looks like from morning to night, including your soul, your family, and your work. Once you know what that day looks like, you start making decisions the way that version of you would, and a lot of meetings, rooms, and environments fall off your calendar quickly.

One question to take with you

I closed by asking Matt for the one thing he would want everyone to walk away with. He asked the room: what’s one thing you know you need to pray over but you’re afraid to? Because you’re afraid of what the answer might be. And that’s exactly where the answer lives.

Want the full conversation? Listen to all three parts of this series on The Table Podcast wherever you get your podcasts, and start with part one so you get the full arc. If this one hit home, I want to hear what you’re sitting with right now. Reply to The Weekly Pour or slide into my DMs. Grab your bevy, and let’s talk.

Previous
Previous

The Table Podcast | Ep. 51: You’re Not Lonely, Your Unavailable

Next
Next

The Table Podcast | Ep. 47: The Summer Duality Nobody Talks About: Motherhood, Momentum and Guilt