Disclaimer: I’m a Flodesk partner and may earn a commission if you sign up through my affiliate link in this post.
Quick answer: You keep your email list warm between launches by sending something personal on a rhythm you can actually keep, and by building real relationships (like ACTUAL real relationships) off the page. My newsletter, The Weekly Pour, goes out from Flodesk about once a month. It averages a 60.7% open rate, higher than my launch emails to the same list.
Okay, confession time. My newsletter is called The Weekly Pour. I have sent it weekly approximately... never. 🫣 I’m a work in progress too, okay?
When Flodesk invited me to write about keeping subscribers warm between launches, I almost wrote the polished version. “Show up every week! Consistency is everything!” Then I actually opened my Flodesk analytics and the numbers told a different, far more honest story of my reality. So that’s the one you’re getting.
How do I keep my email list warm between launches?
For me, making every email feel like it came from a real person is non negotiable. Not a funnel, not an AI robot, not a super well polished version of myself that I am trying to pretend to be. I aim to give people reasons to know me beyond the inbox. For me, warmth comes from relationships first and the send schedule second.
I build community for a living. I host live events, host a podcast, and create community spaces and my whole philosophy is depth over width. Turns out, my email list follows the same rule. The people who open my emails are the people I’ve sat across a table from, shared a resource with, or connected to someone they needed to meet. That’s pretty freaking cool, isn’t it?
The greatest compliment I have ever received is when I meet someone IRL for the first time after being connected with them through my email list or social media and they share a sentiment that goes something like this, “OMG - you’re literally exactly the same IRL as you are online!”. I have to laugh a little because, isn’t that the whole point? Either way, it feels pretty freaking amazing to hear and that compliment is not lost on me.
How often should I email my list?
Email your list as often as you can keep it personal. For me, increasing that frequency is on my focus list for 2027. But as far as this year is concerned, I’ve been averaging sending my newsletter about once a month, and my data says that’s working.
Here’s the real record, straight from my Flodesk account:
17 sends of The Weekly Pour between June 2025 and November 2026. Monthly-ish, not weekly.
60.7% average open rate and 1.7% average click rate across all editions of The Weekly Pour.
My longest gap was 74 days. EEK, I know. Not my proudest moment. But the email after that gap opened at 65.3%.
My last three issues opened at 64.1%, 65.3%, and 68.4%, the highest stretch since my first few sends.
And here’s the plot twist. My launch emails go to the same list. My most recent launch emails, a run of November promos for my live event, opened at 52.4% to 55.0%, with clicks under 1%. My newsletter’s average beats my sales emails by 6 to 8 points.
So no, I’m not telling you to ghost your list for two months. I’m telling you that a skipped week isn’t what makes a list go cold. Treating subscribers exclusively like a sales channel is.
Can you show me a real email that kept your list warm?
I structure my newsletter the same every issue. A title that’s familiar, a structure that resonates and content that connects.
The subject line: The Weekly Pour: Life, Biz + Bevys Served Straight Up
The structure:
The header. The same intro at the top of every issue: I’m Haley, podcast + event host, community expert, wife, 3x girl mom, bevy connoisseur, and lover of a banger playlist. New subscribers instantly know who they’re hearing from and what they can expect going forward.
Life. A little story time with Haley moment sharing what’s been going on in my life right now. Real, raw, slightly unhinged, an opportunity for people to decide if I’m their jam or not (and either way is fine tbh).
Biz. Next up are signature sections Fresh From The Pod and At The Table. An opportunity to share some BTS of recent recordings or upcoming opportunities to connect. Not just the what but also the why and a little bit of everything in between.
Bevys. My fave bevy of the week (or…..cough*month*cough…it’s fine, everything’s fine) because if you know anything about me it’s that I take my bevys VERY seriously. A distinguishable part of my personal brand that makes me memorable on a more personal level.
Faves. A share of something I am loving right now. A product, podcast, book, tech tool, honestly the sky is the limit here. I share the things I’m currently obsessed with because as a real girl’s girl we don’t gatekeep the goods around here.
The results in Flodesk analytics:
My newsletter analytics perform consistently well and a low click rate doesn’t alarm me here. We’re building for the long game which means the focus is on building a culture of reciprocity, trust and relatability with my community.
Although my last newsletter had a 68.4% open rate and a 1.1% click rate, this email format isn’t built to drive clicks. It’s built to make people feel like they know me. Opens tell me people still want to hear from me. Replies tell me they feel close enough to answer back.
How do I grow my email list between launches?
Grow your list with something people genuinely need, then share it everywhere you already show up. For me, that’s been a free resource, not a newsletter signup form.
The Connection Compass is my highest performing free lead magnet for my email list. This application-based living database of must-attend events and must-join communities is designed for people looking for places to plug in. It solves a real problem for my people, so they hand over their email for it. Then The Weekly Pour is what keeps them around.
Here’s where I share it: my IG link in bio, podcast show notes, podcast guesting opportunities, event collaborations with other community hosts, newsletter features in collaborators emails, the footer of my email newsletter and more. You can snag the resource for yourself here.
What if people unsubscribe?
To be perfectly honest this one REALLY used to bother me. Like, where did I go wrong? What was so bad it made them feel inclined to need to leave? But the more I continue to build, the more at peace I feel with this: if they want to go, let them go. Unsubscribes keep your list full of people who actually want to hear from you.
My Nov 1 issue had 2 unsubscribes out of 748 sends and zero spam reports. I call that bless and release. An unsubscribe is someone telling you they aren’t your person right now, and that’s a gift. I’d rather pour into 500 people who open than chase 800 who don’t.
What’s a between-launch email rhythm I can copy?
If you’re not interested in doing a newsletter every week, here’s a cadence I’d strongly consider: one newsletter, one resource, one invitation, and one round of replies. Four moves, one a week. Here’s what I’d hand a friend:
Week 1: Pour. Send your newsletter with a focus on connecting. Life moments, real business lessons, and one bit of pure personality. (Mine’s the bevy, ofc.)
Week 2: Share. Point people to your free resource, on social and in real conversations. This is the part that grows your list.
Week 3: Invite. Invite people somewhere real: a call, an event, a coffee, a walk, etc. This is where subscribers become relationships.
Week 4: Listen. Reply to every response and jot down what people asked about. Congrats, next month’s newsletter just wrote itself.
Your launch emails don’t replace this rhythm. They sit on top of it. And when a launch email lands in an inbox that already got a Pour, an invite, and a reply from you, it reads like news from a friend, not a pitch from a stranger.
Does a bigger email list cost more on Flodesk?
Flodesk’s unlimited plans are back, with unlimited subscribers and unlimited emails for one flat price. Plans start at $38 a month, billed annually. I’ve been a Flodesk member since 2022, and now every time the Connection Compass brings someone new to my table, I never have to weigh that sign-up against my bill.
What else do people ask about keeping an email list warm?
Do I really need to email my list every week?
Not necessarily. My newsletter goes out about once a month and averages a 60.7% open rate. My plan for 2027 is to commit to a weekly email cadence to my list but that may not be for everyone. Pick the rhythm you can keep personal (and consistent), and stick with it.
Should I sell in my newsletter between launches?
Keep most issues offer-free so your list doesn’t learn that your emails exclusively mean a pitch. If you want to softly mention your offers keep them in the p.s. or place them somewhere thoughtfully so it genuinely feels like a value add. With that being said, I wouldn’t neglect sales emails completely! Be strategic about your email marketing rather than flying by the seat of your pants if possible.
Do I need a freebie to grow my email list?
Not necessarily but it does help a lot. My free Connection Compass resource has brought in 222 opt-ins in Flodesk in about a year and it has honestly been shared more passively than I would like to admit. I need to be better about incorporating it into my social media stories etc. more often!
What’s a good open rate for a small email list?
The best benchmark is your own. Pick a target and focus on improving it month after month. I did some online research and the best data that I could find was that open rates over 50% are considered excellent (especially for smaller lists like mine that that are built on real relationships). My Weekly Pour open rate currently averages a 60.7% open rate and my last issue from November 1st went to 750 subscribers. Watch your trend over time, and pay attention to replies, not just opens. Those are the margins where real connection is built.
Why is my newsletter’s click rate so low?
A low click rate is normal when an email isn’t built around focus on links. My Nov 1 issue had a 68.4% open rate and a 1.1% click rate, because its job was connection, not traffic.
So what should I send my list this month?
Send one personal email to your list with nothing to sell. Keeping your list warm isn’t about hitting send every Tuesday. It’s about being a real person people want to hear from, and giving them a reason to stay. Relatability is a key to the long game here and getting people to stick around.
Want to see how I do it? Join The Weekly Pour here
Ready to start your own list? Try Flodesk with my affiliate link: Flodesk Partner Link
Now tell me: what’s one email you could send this month with nothing to sell?

